3 min read

Trust vs. will: How to Choose the Right Estate Planning Tool


Trust vs. will: How to Choose the Right Estate Planning Tool

Talk about some interesting bequests. 

Shakespeare left his wife his “second-best bed,” a gesture that was either romantic or insulting. Leona Helmsley left $12 million to her dog. And Napoleon included a demand in his will that his head be shaved after his death, with each of his friends getting a tuft. 

Estate planning can be practical and also sometimes preposterous. But it should always be personal. 

The process is often more complicated than people expect. Beyond just writing a will, estate planning involves strategic decisions about trusts, Transfer on Death (TOD) accounts, tax implications, and even how family dynamics will shape asset distribution. Laws vary by state, and things like probate, your beneficiary designations, and long-term financial management must all be carefully considered.  

Americans clearly don’t feel too confident: A recent survey from Caring.com reported that two-thirds of U.S. adults have no established estate plan. Yet, without a plan, your loved ones may face unnecessary legal battles, financial burdens or delays. Understanding your options is essential to creating a comprehensive estate strategy tailored to your needs. 

But should you choose a will? A trust? TOD? Maybe some combination? Choosing the right mix depends on your financial situation, family dynamics and estate planning goals. 

What are the differences between a will and a trust? 

As a legal document that outlines who will receive your assets after your death, a will allows you to name an executor to manage your estate, appoint guardians for your minor children, and specify how you want your assets to be distributed. 

While a will is usually cost-effective and simple to create, a will also must go through probate and it’s also part of the public record, which means anyone can look up who got what. A will can also be contested, which – depending on your family dynamics – could lead to some ugly family disputes. 

Then there’s a trust, a legal entity that holds assets for beneficiaries. A trust can exist in two forms: 

  • Revocable trusts (also known as living trusts) allow you to make changes or revoke them while you’re alive. 
  • Irrevocable trusts cannot be modified once they’re created but offer a higher level of asset protection and tax advantages. 

A trust is not only private and confidential, but it also avoids the probate process entirely, which speeds up asset distribution. A trust also allows for incapacity planning, which can make the management of assets much more seamless if you’re suddenly unable to handle your financial matters. However, trusts are more complex to set up than wills, and they’re usually more expensive to create. 

Do I really need a trust? 

Many of our clients assume a trust is a necessary part of estate planning, but that’s not always the case. In fact, a trust may be overkill for certain situations: 

  • Small estates: If your assets are straightforward – a home, bank accounts and some retirement funds – a will and TOD designations may be sufficient. 
  • No privacy concerns: If you don’t mind your estate going through probate, a trust may not be necessary. 
  • Cost considerations: Trusts require legal setup and ongoing management, which can rack up costs. If probate costs are lower than the fees for setting up the trust, a will might be the better choice for you. 
  • Certain state laws: Some states have streamlined probate processes, making a trust not as necessary. 

What are some alternatives to a trust? 

Trusts are powerful tools, but they’re not one-size-fits-all. Consider some various alternatives: 

  • Transfer on Death (TOD) accounts: A TOD is used to designate a beneficiary who will inherit an asset (such as real estate, stocks, bonds, etc.) upon the owner's death, which allows the asset to bypass the probate process. They’re fairly simple to set up and allow for immediate transfer without any legal delays. 
  • Beneficiary designations: Ensure all your life insurance and retirement accounts have updated beneficiary designated, which makes the transfer of these assets quick and easy. 
  • Will: A well-drafted will prepared by an attorney can clearly outline your wishes, ensuring assets are distributed appropriately and quickly. 

What role do family dynamics play in estate planning? 

Estate planning goes beyond just your assets; it’s also about relationships. Your immediate family members and how they relate to each other play a critical role in your estate planning strategy, as well as preventing conflicts and ensuring a fair distribution. 

Clear communication is really the key to avoiding misunderstandings. As appropriate, try to discuss your estate plan with family members to make sure everyone’s on the same page, and make sure you’re consistent with your beneficiary designations across your will, trust and any TOD accounts. 

At the end of the day, of course, the choice is always yours. But making an attempt to balance fairness and your existing family dynamics will go a long way to ensure no one feels left out. 

Consult a financial professional for sound advice 

No matter what assets you have, choosing among a trust, will or TOD accounts all depends on your financial situation, the size of your estate, family dynamics and your own personal preferences. The best solution for you might be the use of multiple estate planning tools to ensure your assets are distributed according to your wishes while minimizing legal complexities. 

If you’re ready to create a plan tailored to your needs – even if it means bequeathing your own shaved hair – we’re here to help and offer our expert advice. The important part is to stop waiting! 

Estate Planning: An Introduction

Estate Planning: An Introduction

By definition, estate planning is a process designed to help you manage and preserve your assets while you are alive, and to conserve and control...

Read More
Lessons to Learn From: Real-Life Estate Planning Tales From the Trenches

Lessons to Learn From: Real-Life Estate Planning Tales From the Trenches

We’ve all heard the estate planning horror stories, known someone who spent years trying to untangle a legal mess when a loved one died, retold...

Read More
Exploring Your Options: Understanding Medicare Coverage

Exploring Your Options: Understanding Medicare Coverage

Medicare is a federal program that provides health insurance to retired individuals, regardless of their medical condition, and certain younger...

Read More